A group of lawyers is asking for an inquiry into whether New Zealand spy agencies are supporting Israel’s actions in Gaza. They wrote to Inspector-General Brendan Horsley, warning that New Zealand could be involved in international crimes. Horsley is considering their request and has said he will look at spying related to conflicts this year.
One lawyer, Treasa Dunworth, believes the inquiry is important because it raises questions about how the Government Communications Security Bureau (GCSB) and the Security Intelligence Service (NZSIS) share intelligence with Israel, possibly through the United States. Dunworth said they provided strong evidence for their request.
The letter states the GCSB and NZSIS might be breaking New Zealand laws and ethical standards through their actions in relation to Gaza. Dunworth and her colleagues, Vinod Bal and Dr. Max Harris, believe the inquiry is needed to boost public trust in these agencies. They argue that even if no intelligence is shared, the inquiry would help people feel more confident in the processes of New Zealand’s spy agencies.
Horsley had previously mentioned that he would keep an eye on intelligence activities connected to ongoing conflicts, including those in Gaza. He has not committed to specific inquiries but said he would monitor the situation closely.
The lawyers provided a detailed 38-page document to support their request, fearing New Zealand might be contributing to illegal actions. Recent UN inquiries mentioned war crimes on both sides of the Gaza conflict, and those findings raised more concerns.
The lawyers highlighted that New Zealand is part of the Five Eyes intelligence network, which might mean that any intelligence collected could end up aiding Israel. They also pointed out that New Zealand’s Defence Force is involved in US-led operations, which may indirectly support Israel’s actions in Gaza.
The spy agencies stated they act according to government priorities and take human rights seriously. They emphasized that all their activities, including working with foreign authorities, must follow New Zealand law. They welcome the independent oversight from the Inspector-General.
